The launch of an e-ticketing system in Sindh has been declared unlawful by the Sindh High Court (SHC), following a hearing where it was revealed actions were taken before proper gazette notification. Petitions were filed by various groups, including the Jamaat-i-Islami and the Karachi Bus Owners Association.
E-Ticketing System Launch Without Gazette Notification
During the hearing on Thursday, it emerged that the provincial government commenced issuing e-challans and imposing fines in October. However, the crucial notification amending the Motor Vehicle Ordinance, 1965, was only published in the official gazette on December 1.
One of the petitioners’ lawyers highlighted this discrepancy, arguing that all subsequent actions were consequently unlawful. The bench expressed concern, urging officials to thoroughly examine all legal aspects before implementing legislation.
The court also called on officials to consider ground realities. Judges noted instances where citizens might face undue delays at traffic lights, even in low-traffic situations, potentially posing security risks. SindhNews.com has followed these developments closely.
Legal Aspects of E-Ticketing
Despite the legal challenge, the court observed a positive impact on city traffic following the e-challan system’s introduction. A government lawyer requested more time to submit comments, stating that traffic accidents had reportedly decreased by 50 percent.
The bench has directed the chief secretary, home secretary, excise and taxation department, and police officials to file a comprehensive report by January 15, 2026. The court previously refused to grant a stay on the e-challan system.
The petitioners contend the AI-based system was implemented without adequate road infrastructure or vehicle ownership verification. They argue the state cannot impose heavy fines without providing essential facilities for lawful driving.